Pat McAfee chides ‘College Gameday’ trolls ahead of return, ESPN’s beloved college football pregame show, “College Gameday,” is set to make a splash next week with a special episode from Dublin, Ireland. Among the familiar faces returning to the show is Pat McAfee, whose presence has stirred a range of reactions from fans and critics alike.
Pat McAfee, a former NFL punter turned sports media personality, has become one of the most talked-about figures on “College Gameday.” His unconventional style and larger-than-life persona have made him a polarizing addition to the panel. While many fans appreciate his energetic and often irreverent approach, others have found his antics grating.
McAfee’s recent Instagram post—featuring a shirtless photo of himself on the “College Gameday” set—only intensified the debate. The post was met with a flood of comments, many of which were critical of McAfee’s on-screen behavior. The backlash was a reminder of the divided opinions surrounding his role on the show.

Another critic labeled McAfee a “redneck” and suggested he should keep his shirt on. McAfee’s response was both sarcastic and defiant. “Damn shame… I don’t love that you’ve stopped watching maybe we’ll be able to get you back this year,” he quipped. “If so, we’ll have the third straight season of highest ratings ever. WE NEED YA.” His playful banter reflects his confidence and resilience in the face of criticism.
The 2023 college football season was a notable one for “College Gameday,” achieving its second-highest viewership since 2011 with an average of 2.0 million viewers. This was just shy of the record set in 2022, which saw an average of 2.1 million viewers. McAfee’s contributions, whether loved or loathed, appear to have played a role in maintaining the show’s high ratings.
McAfee’s social media exchanges also included a response to a comment from someone who claimed to have vomited upon seeing his post. McAfee’s retort was characteristically sharp: “Could’ve been the mirror you walked by.” His ability to turn criticism into humor is a hallmark of his public persona.
